The Philisophical Origins of Frugality: Why are you Frugal?

Frugality. As Peter Griffin’s ancestor, the great philosopher Thomas Griffin, would say, “Whyyy??”. Where did the concept of ‘frugality’ come from? And what compels us to follow it? Does frugality have origins in spiritual or religious belief? Are there emotional triggers that inspire us to be frugal? Are we just stingy bastards who will end up dying with a loaded bank account? Let’s discuss.
Frugality in Spirituality
A number of religious and spiritual groups, past and present, have touted frugality as a means for spending less on oneself in order to:
- live a life less reliant on material possessions.
- allow us to save more money to give to charitable causes.
Both are undoubtedly strong virtues and I can see why a spiritual or religious person, in practice, could be fulfilled through the practice of frugality.
Back to the Basics Philosophy
Not to dissimilar from religious and spiritual philosophy is the ‘back-to-the-basics’ school of thought, whereby removing debt and material clutter from your life can lead to a sense of fulfillment. There is a counter-consumer movement worldwide that is rooted in the belief that one will much more easily find a satisfied life if they can limit the amount of economical and material baggage that they are indebted to.
Environmentalism & Frugality
Environmentalists everywhere have touted a frugal lifestyle. We’ve all seen how saving on materials, water, energy, and transportation has not only led to monetary savings, but have a significant impact on the environment as well. The tiny house movement is a combination of environmentalism, de-cluttering, and frugality.
Frugality Driven by Fear & Obsession
There are certainly people who are driven to be frugal from emotions such as fear. Fear can lead people to want to pinch every single penny so that they won’t run out of money, fall into debt, or maybe they are simply afraid to give up their hard earned money. When kept in check, a little fear around spending too much is a healthy thing, but it rarely should ever be the only reason why you are frugal in every monetary situation. A focus on the fear can lead to obsession and that’s when you get stories of people who don’t spend a dime on anything and die alone with millions in the bank.
Wealth & Frugality
Frugality is a practice that can have a significant impact one of the two defining factors in building wealth: expense and income. Living below your means and spending less than you earn is key to building wealth and seeking future goals such as early retirement, purchasing a home, going back to school, etc.
Situation
There are simply times when financial situation forces us to be frugal. Earlier this year, when my wife was laid off, I was rudely reminded of this reality.
Personal Motivators for Frugality
For me personally, each of the above triggers has inspired me to be frugal at one point or another. When I was in college, I was driven by fear that I would never build enough savings to buy a home or retire. This fear drove me to the point of obsession. I probably turned a lot of people off in this phase. I can happily say that I have moved on.
After school, building wealth was a motivating factor for me to be frugal. I’ve set long-term goals to become self employed, pay off my mortgage, and retire early. None of these goals could be accomplished without a little frugality. This passion for the frugal-to-wealth approach is the primary reason why I started MicroFrugality.
Most recently, I have been driven to be frugal through spiritual, minimalist, and environmental reasons. With career, family, and material commitments at times becoming overwhelming and leading to stress, I truly believe that if I can limit the amount of financial and material baggage in my life, I will be less stressed, more focused, and happier.
Why Are YOU Frugal?
- What are the motivating reasons why you are frugal?
- Have you gone through stages that motivated you in different ways to be frugal?
- Where do you think the origins of frugality began?



Well, for me it was partly just carrying on the lifestyle that my family led when I was growing up. My parents were really frugal because we were poor – and so I’ve always been uncomfortable spending money.
Now that I’ve graduated (newly minted PhD with $100K in student loan debt and $15K in credit card debt, making $40K per year) I have to be frugal because I can’t afford to be anything else. I have been working about a year and a half now and only have $4K of credit card debt left – the goal is to pay off that debt, save until I have an e-fund of ~$10K (I have $4K now), pay off the portion of my student loans that’s at 6.8% interest, then change my repayment plan on the bulk of my loans from graduated to fixed and open a Roth IRA.
Along the way, I’ve given up the fancy lotion, fancy hair product, and getting my hair colored (among other things). Maybe someday I’ll be able to afford that stuff again, but not right now.
My main motivation is to buy investment houses. And if I’m successful, this will provide more income and security.
I have about 6 girlfriends. The ones that are frugal, have beautiful houses. The ones that love spending on high-end brands and top-notch dining, have either no house, or an old run-down house that requires a lot of renovating.
I started being frugal in university when I wanted to accumulate more clothes and clutter, like my friends, but I didn’t have a job.
When I first got to make decisions with money, I wasn’t very frugal, buying breakfast and lunch each day. As soon as I started tracking my spending, I decided what was worth it and what was a waste of money.
I haven’t gone through different stages. My attitude is still the same. And I grew up poor, so I am used to being frugal, I don’t like to waste things.
I’m a spender by nature, but after selling my time for 40 hours a week I figured I should save some of the rewards instead of splurging on things I don’t need.
My motivations for being frugal definitely stem from spiritual, minimalist, and environmental reasons. I am actually not a very frugal person by nature but this year my husband and I embarked on a year of not spending money. We are only buying groceries (mostly). It sounds more extreme than it really is in practice.
One of the other readers said that she was following the practices she grew up with; well, not me! My parents have been married for 30 years and I would be surprised if they have more $500 in their savings account! I am slowly learning to change my ways.
Thanks for your work here! Very interesting.
Leave a comment!
Get your Free MicroFrugal Fix!
Topics
Archives
Polls
Frugal Services & Products
Blogroll
Blogroll
Tag Cloud
text